When M was five weeks old, she ended up in the hospital with a fever. It turned out she was just strep, but the bills were huge. My husband’s company medical insurance was a huge blessing and since we’d met the deductible with her birth, we paid little to no money out of pocket.
A year later, along came Obamacare. Since it was now mandated that companies pay for hormonal birth control and the morning after pill, my husband’s and my consciences could no longer allow us to buy into his company’s insurance plan. That left us searching for alternatives.
What we found:
After sorting through the options (there are a few…not many, but a few…) we settled on Medi-Share. It was the one that made the most sense for our family and also is set up most like “regular” health insurance. The way it works is this. Each month, we send in our “share” (premium). When a “need” (claim) arises, it is first adjusted down just like traditional insurance would adjust it. If the Annual Household Portion (deductible) hasn’t been met, we (the member) pay the remaining amount. If the AHP has been met, Medi-Share pays for it with the shares that have been sent in during the previous months. Sound just like traditional insurance? Well, it pretty much is.
What we don’t like:
I thought I’d list what we don’t like first since there really isn’t much.
- There are no guarantees. This isn’t “insurance”. If the money isn’t there, the need can’t be met. That said, our needs have all been met. If they come up short one month, they send out an email saying how short they are and asking for contributions. For as long as we’ve been members, those extra contributions have always come in. I really look at this as a faith thing. This is a Christian organization and each member is stepping out in faith trusting God to fill in the missing pieces.
What we like:
- You aren’t paying for bad habits. Because the Bible teaches that our bodies are temples, Medi-Share does not allow people who smoke, drink a lot, or do drugs. When we signed up, Brian and I both had to sign a form saying that we’d report each other if one of us broke the rules.
- Pregnancy is supported. Married pregnancies are covered by health sharing. Unmarried pregnancies aren’t paid for, but members are directed to resources for unwed mothers. They receive lots of support and love. Abortion is not paid for.
- Prayer is commonplace. When you call customer support or talk to anyone from Medi-Share for any reason, they always end the phone call with a prayer. They ask how they can pray for you and then they do. It’s amazingly different than a phone call to a traditional health insurance company.
- They ask you to be in prayer. Each month, you receive an email with the name of the person your share helped support. Though there is no private information shared, they ask you to pray for that person. There is also a place on the member’s website where you can post specific prayer requests and other members can pray for you.
- It’s worked for us! The adjustments have been just as significant as “regular” insurance adjustments would have been and we’ve had no trouble making payments and receiving support.
- The cost is reasonable. It was more expensive than what we paid before Obamacare, but I’ve heard it’s less expensive than what insurance costs most families now that Obamacare is in place.
Want to join?
I’d love it if you use my referral link to sign up! It seems confusing, but it’s really not…at least not any more confusing than traditional insurance! And calling customer service for help understanding things usually ends up being a blessing…not a headache!
I hope this has helped you. Tell me, do you use an alternative to traditional health insurance?

That’s REALLY sad that you dropped insurance over HBC which is not just used for birth control. And if taken correctly prevents ovulation. People do take that for medical reasons such endometriosis, heavy or irregular periods. The morning after pill is NOT the abortion pill, please do research. The pill prevents the egg and sperm from uniting. If you are already pregnant it does it does not cause an abortion.
Just wanted to let you know I removed your last sentence as name calling and unkind remarks won’t be permitted on my blog. I’m happy to discuss issues you may have with my stance on birth control and the research I’ve done over email, but I won’t be doing it here. There are plenty of websites where those debates can happen, but this isn’t one of them as this is my happy place and a place I want other moms to be able to come and feel safe and respected. This is a debate-free zone. Thanks!
We joined a healthcare sharing ministry over three years ago (Samaritan Ministries). While looking at options to traditional insurance, I looked at Medi-Share but we settled on Samaritan. I like that we send money directly to a family with a medical need each month instead of to the company. We have also been blessed to have all our “needs” met. It really is easier than insurance and so much more personal! I also like that we are not “punished” for having kids…our monthly share stays the same no matter how many kids we have!
Yes! I should have put that as one of my reasons for loving Medi-Share! You can pay for one person, two people, or three plus! We just added our new baby and he didn’t cost a thing! It is a blessing to have a company that sees children as a blessing. 🙂
Thanks for the great explanation! I have been looking into these type of sharing programs and been totally confused! Your post may have help us in our decision! 🙂
God bless!
I’ve never heard of such a thing! I would be really worried that the money wouldn’t be there, or that there wouldn’t be enough…
As a Catholic, I know the issue of hormonal birth control and the morning after pill has come up a lot since Obamacare was passed. I think it’s fantastic you were able to find coverage that fits with your beliefs.